Now, I'm all for teenage rebellion. It's a natural part of growing up. As children approach adulthood, the want to make their own choices is nothing but instinctual, and the restraints placed upon them at a young age are gradually lifted. Naturally, these restraints can take many forms, but the most common include face and body piercings and the dyeing of one's hair.
I too have made the point of partaking in both - I have two rings in both earlobes and I dyed my hair last Christmas - however unlike the case I am about to bring up, I DID in fact wait until I was 18 to do both, the former under the wishes of my parents, the latter because until then I hadn't really fancied having my hair any other colour.
THIS article here, which was posted this morning on the Daily Mail website, is from a mother (Diana Appleyard) who believes that she has, in some way, failed in her duties as a parent because her 18 year-old daughter (Charlotte) has several piercings and dyed her hair all manner of colours. She also, quite infuriatingly, ponders on whether it is her daughter's love for heavy metal music that has caused her to invest in the aforementioned activities. She says that her daughter "first dyed her hair in her third year at boarding school — I went to pick her up for a day out and nearly fainted with shock. Her gorgeous blonde hair had been dyed a horrible matte black. Against it, her skin seemed pasty and washed out. She looked, in short, nothing like my daughter." The article goes on to say "Her father and I worked so hard to give her and her sister an idyllic childhood, with horses and private education — yet Charlotte looks the antithesis of her upbringing."
To this, I write the following response:
Firstly, Diana, your dream image of how your daughter would turn out was always going to be dashed. As mentioned above, teenage rebellion is part of growing up, and every single one does so in their own unique way. Your daughter is not unlike the rest of us, and I am sure you too had your own way of going against the grain. True, some aspects of childhood never fade - 16 years down the line, I am still an avid fan of Chelsea Football Club. I have also maintained a great love for the Beano comics and continue to enjoy The Pink Panther and Wacky Races. However, I was always looking for that element of self-expression, and I found it, like Charlotte, in heavy metal music. Now, sitting in my room in my student house, no fewer than four posters of Iron Maiden adorn my walls, and I even have a drawer filled with all manner of band t-shirts. I reckon that, if you spoke to Charlotte about it, there would be things that she still loves regardless of how she has 'evolved' as a human being.
You also say that your daughter's appearance "has become a family joke" and that you "wonder if there is something I have done wrong". To put it bluntly, you haven't. I assume I became the same way - at 17, my hair was past my shoulders and I more or less lived out of my denim waistcoat and studded wristbands. My hair was always the first thing to be commented on at family gatherings, and it wouldn't surprise me at all if my younger brother ridiculed me at school to his friends about the whole affair. Neither of my parents were ever embarrassed about what I was wearing, and the only time they were was when I wore a t-shirt displaying a '666' logo, which offended them due to their Christian faith. In the end, my dad bought the t-shirt off me and disposed of it, and I went out and bought a different one with the money. Win win situation.
Now on to the point that has really got my goat - the issue of heavy metal music itself. Metal has never attempted to be the image of 'popular music' - sure, the moments that it DOES breach the top 20 in the UK charts are applauded, but no band has ever sought out to become a mainstream metal act, nor have the fans ever tried to consistently get a band to #1. To do so is to go against the flow of what heavy metal is about - the close-knit community and the decision to move away from the 'norm' and band together. A band could play music as heavy as Slayer, for example, but if they regularly released singles and tried to claim the top spot in the charts with each release, quickly people would perceive them to be 'selling out' and they would lose a lot of fans. A perfect case in point is Metallica - the biggest metal band on the planet, yet when they released 'The Black Album' in 1991, the move away from 8-minute epics to 5-minute, almost radio-friendly tunes alienated quite a few people, of which some have never forgiven the band for that decision. The overall point is this: Metal has always been, in its foundations, about people wanting to create music as far way as possible from what was and what IS present in the Top 40 and to EXPRESS THEMSELVES in their own way. Your daughter is no different. As I mentioned above, the development from child to teenager is always accompanied by some form of expression.
I would also like to try and quell your fears that Charlotte's "aggressive image might damage her in some way". This is not the case at all. I can definitely see your view - a lot of band t-shirts have quite graphic designs on them, and coupled with the other stereotypical features - lots of black, numerous piercings, studded accessories - the result can be quite 'scary' to an extent. However, deep down, Charlotte will still have the "sweet, dreamy personality" that you say she has. The same holds true for the vast majority of the alternative community. It is one big family, brought together under a love for all things heavy and loud. Everyone comes from different walks of life, and will all continue to take different paths. There are footballers who like metal, actors, even politicians. The only thing in common is the taste in music. There is nothing that says to be a metalhead, you must have an aggressive attitude towards everyone. Again, take me - I've loved heavy metal since the age of 11, but I am a Christian like my parents and, according to everyone I know, one of the nicest and most sensitive guys around. Not exactly the toughest or most aggressive of people, am I? However, on a different note, do not expect this to be "just a phase". The strength of the community means most carry on the image right into adulthood and for the rest of their lives. That's just the way it is and the way it always has been.
In closing then, Diana, I would like to say that you have NOT been a bad mother in any sense of the word, and that's it's perfectly normal to be worried. However, I stand by Charlotte and urge you to "butt out" of her life somewhat. Not only are you taking everything far too personally, but now that she is 18 and legally a young adult, she is free to do what she wants. Of course, that doesn't mean you cannot ADVISE her and give your opinion where you feel necessary, but ultimately it is HER decision on whether she gets that band t-shirt, or that piercing, or that tattoo. I would also like to stress that heavy metal music is NOT making your daughter aggressive. If anything, the nature of the music is keeping her charming self intact. If you do ever read this, then I hope you take what I have said on board and that it gives you some piece of mind. If you are still genuinally worried, then I suggest you speak to her properly. Have a good, honest conversation, with no raised voices, and let her tell you everything. I'm sure it will become clear that she is not out to harm you and (hopefully) it will make your relationship even stronger.
Yours,
Elliot Leaver