In the big story of the week, the cancellation of Sonisphere was announced. The
organisers said it was due to an impossibility to put on a festival fit
for the fans, and the official statement can be read here. Whilst I respect their decision and applaud them for not attempting to put on a half-assed festival, I do feel they only have themselves to blame for the
following reasons:
1)
The lineup was not as strong as previous years. True, the headliners
were massive: KISS, Queen + Adam Lambert and Faith No More, but even
THEY couldn't stand up to the previous years of Metallica, Iron Maiden
and Slipknot, to name three. Also, the undercard wasn't as strong,
despite the announcements of Refused and three bands playing albums in
full (Glassjaw, Mastodon and Hundred Reasons). The lineup just didn't
stand up to the stellar bill that Download has put together this year.
That therefore would have been a factor in potentially poor ticket
sales. However, Sonisphere made one fatal decision:
2) They announced far too late. By the time they had announced the first batch of bands, Download had a huge lineup and people who had needed to book time off work for the summer had had to do so. The trouble as well was Sonisphere, only going into it's fourth year, was still too new to have established a following like Reading/Leeds or Glastonbury where tickets are often almost sold out from the moment early bird tickets go on sale after the festival has finished. Hell, even DOWNLOAD hasn't got that, and rock festivals have been held at Donington for over 30 years. If Sonisphere had announced KISS with Metallica, Queen with Sabbath, FNM with The Prodigy then they probably would still be going ahead. Last year's headliner battle was immense:
-Download announce the return of System of a Down after a 5 year hiatus. Everybody goes mental
-Two days later, Sonisphere announce Slipknot, on their first tour since the death of bassist Paul Gray. Knebworth is set to be the last date. Everyone goes even more mental.
-Sonisphere confirm Biffy Clyro to headline the Saturday night in their first ever festival headline slot. Opinions are vastly divided.
-Download follow suit by revealing Linkin Park as their Sunday night headliner. Opinions divided again.
-Sonisphere attempt to bury the hatchet with the confirmation of The Big 4 on the Friday night: Anthrax, Megadeth, Slayer and headliners Metallica one after the other, with Diamond Head opening, leaving Download to come up with something truly special.
-Download bring back Def Leppard as their final headliner, which seems very underwhelming. Advantage Sonisphere.
I therefore feel that even though people would have still said Download had the stronger lineup, Sonisphere would not have got itself into the mess that it did.
3)I believe the festival was struggling to book bands: many were exclusive to Download or Reading/Leeds and therefore could not be announced until after those respective festivals were over (in the case of R/L then, not at all). Touring commitments would have also meant a no-show, whilst other events taking place in the UK this year have already had an effect: the Big Chill was cancelled because they were struggling to book acts owing to the Olympics. Similarly, Glastonbury moved forward their 'break' year amid concerns of a portaloo shortage. Perhaps these also combined to result in the cancellation? I do wonder whether Sonisphere approached certain bands, but as they couldn't promise the bands when they would be announced, the bands themselves turned down the offers. That's just speculation though, as indeed, it all is.
So, Soni '12 is a no-go: will there be a 2013? The answer is we just don't know: there was no confirmation of a festival next year in the official statement and with the news that Sonisphere Italy is facing a similar fate, a rumour that the company has gone bust is slowly rumbling round. However, Italy is in a worse finanicial state than us, and whilst Sonisphere doesn't have the demand that Glastonbury and R/L do, I am more than certain there is enough demand for Download to continue having a main rival to battle in the quest for the UK's premier rock festival. I am sure we will see. I'm pencilling the 5-7th July and the 12-14th as dates for Sonisphere 2013, back at Knebworth, where it belongs.